Quick SNITCH

A quantitative guide to the degree of difficulty of the Times Quick Cryptic Crossword

Solver Types and a Neutrino Detector

The SNITCH has always relied on a set of Reference solvers to calculate the difficulty of the crossword. Updating this list over time has led me to look at different types of solver. In particular, it has been important to detect and remove "Neutrinos" from the data (see further below). Once this is done we can look at other types of solver more clearly.

What's a Neutrino?

Neutrino – A person who manually solves the puzzle on paper, and then goes to the Crossword Club and types in the answers as rapidly as possible, either in order to give a high position on the leaderboard or because they are entering a typing competition. (Times for the Times glossary definition)

Have you noticed that the top of the Times Cryptic Crossword Club leaderboard is occupied by solvers who have some remarkable completion times? How does someone solve the puzzle in around 2 minutes, when it probably takes that long to just write in the answers?

On the Times for the Times blog site, we've come to know these solvers as "Neutrinos", a term coined by Tony Sever some years back to describe those people who like to occupy the top spots on the leaderboard without actually being top-notch solvers. The theory is that these people do the crossword on paper, then transcribe the answers on the Crossword Club interface.

And the big question is: how can we detect these? Some of them are pretty obvious: if you look at the results at the table on the right, the top solver in recent months is Wee Davie with an average solving time of 01:36 (min:sec). Given that this is faster than average times of the known best solvers, we're sure that this is not a real solving time. But it's much harder to tell when you're talking about average times that are in the realms of possibility. Who are the Neutrinos and who are the real solvers? This page tries to answer that question.

Clusters of solvers

The chart below indicates a way to separate Neutrinos from other solvers. It plots each solver's average solving time (in seconds) on the x-axis against an "alignment to SNITCH" factor on the y-axis. This alignment factor is close to 1 when, on average, a solver's personal NITCH rating for a crossword is close to the SNITCH rating for that crossword. It is 0 when there is no alignment. (For those interested, more detail on this is provided below).

The blue dots on this chart represent the Reference solvers for the SNITCH as of Sep 2023. (Note that you can hover over each point to see the name of the individual solver.) These original Reference solvers were chosen because, when I inspected the data manually, they seemed to have the right spread of results. As you'd expect, on the graph below most of these blue dots are clustered around an alignment factor of 1 (generally between 0.5 and 1.5) regardless of their average solving time.

The red dots represent solvers who have been around for some time but were not used as Reference solvers at the time shown above. Some of these have a SNITCH alignment factor close to 1. It's likely that these solvers should have been included as Reference solvers, but I missed them in the original manual analysis.

The grey dots represent solvers who weren't around at the time the Reference solver list was baselined in Sep 2023. When I start to pick up their results the question arises: should I include them as Reference solvers or not?

You'll see there's a cluster of dots (especially red and grey ones) in the lower left corner of this graph. These solvers have low average solving times and their alignment factor is close to 0. These are the classic-style Neutrinos - those who are very fast on average, regardless of how hard the puzzles are.

I investigated this clustering of results and determined that any solver with a solving time of less than 4.3 minutes and a SNITCH alignment factor of less than 0.5 could be safely classified as a Neutrino. This has allowed me to distinguish genuine fast solvers (including some that I missed originally) from the classic-style Neutrinos (a few of which I originally classed as Reference solvers). It has been invaluable in cleaning up the top of the leaderboard. And it means that new solvers can be automatically classified and that this is reliable in most cases.

There are a number of solvers that have low SNITCH alignment but longer solving times. They are not topping the leaderboards (which, we think, is what drives the classic Neutrino behaviour). But, whatever the cause, I regard these solvers as inappropriate candidates for Reference solvers. If they have a SNITCH alignment factor of less than 0.2, I mark them as Neutrinos. If it's up to 0.5 I mark them as Tracked solvers so that their results appear but are not included in the SNITCH calculations.

Remaining Questions

We see that some solvers have alignment to the SNITCH figures well above 1, which would suggest that they seem to find harder puzzles especially hard. These solvers often have small data sets, including those with relatively high average solving times that don't always make the top 100 on the leaderboard. With the smaller amount of data, the alignment is likely to be less reflective of their true performance.

Blog Solvers: adding solving times from the blog

On the Times for the Times blog site, solvers regularly report their solving times. Where they have allowed it, we now add them to the list of solvers and track their progress. This is a new category of solver, the Blog Solver, for those who've reported solving times regularly over the last six months.

Notes to Blog Solvers:

  • the most reliable format for reporting times is with format "mm:ss" or as "x minutes" in the title or at the start of the entry
  • only the first main comment for each blogger is used; responses to other comments or a second comment is ignored.
  • to report errors, include "n errors" just after the time
  • If you just have a time it is assumed you have no errors unless you mention DNF or pink squares or giving up, etc, in the text
  • Examples of good time notifications are "38:30, 0 errors" and "39 minutes, 0 errors" in the comment title or as the first part of your comment
  • This info is also available using the "Blog Solver" button on the right hand side of the detailed crossword solving times for each crossword

Updating solver status

This analysis allows me to reclassify solvers, as shown in the chart below. One of my main motivations is to be able to update the list of Reference solvers reliably. I'd like to be able to include new solvers (especially good ones) without accidentally including Neutrinos. And I'd like to track other non-Reference and non-Neutrino solvers, even if their data isn't used for the SNITCH.

So I can now classify solvers as follows:

Neutrino
Those with fast solving times and low or inconsistent alignment to the SNITCH (shown in orange)
Reference Solvers
Those aligned to the SNITCH and having an average solving time of less than 45 mins (shown in blue)
Tracked Solvers
Those that don't meet the conditions for Reference Solvers but I can be fairly sure are not Neutrinos (shown in red)
Blog Solvers
Those that report their solving times in the Times for the Times site (shown in purple)

New solvers will come into the list over time and can be reclassified on my next update.

I've shown the old and new status in the full table to the right so that you can track the changes for each user. This table is refreshed at the end of each month.

So what's the SNITCH alignment factor?

This is actually pretty straightforward if you know a little maths. I plot the solver's individual NITCH scores agains the corresponding SNITCH for the same puzzle and measure the slope of the line of best fit. A slope of 1 indicates that the results are proportional, a slope of 0 means that there's no correlation.

For example, Verlaine has results as shown in the chart below. Easier puzzles (according to the SNITCH) are on the left of the x-axis, harder ones on the right. Verlaine's NITCH results vary, but are generally higher as we progress from left to right. The overall slope of the line of best fit is close to 1, showing good alignment with the SNITCH on average.

In contrast, look at the results in the chart below. There is no correlation with the hardness of the puzzle according to the SNITCH. In fact, the slope is negative, meaning that on average the harder puzzles are easier for this solver than the easier ones. This lack of correlation is exactly what you'd expect if the solver is just typing in known answers.

Solving times for club members

The table below shows crossword club solvers who have submitted more than 20 solutions in the last six months, with an average solving time of less than 60 minutes for an error-free crossword. The non-Neutrino solvers are ranked by that solving time. It also indicates their status, including whether they are Reference solvers for calculation of the daily SNITCH.

Rank Solver Status - Sep 2023 Current Status Average Time SNITCH Alignment
Wee Davie new_solver neutrino 01:36 -0.08
niqo new_solver neutrino 01:45 0.22
niq.dow tracked neutrino 01:45 0.24
1 mohn reference reference 02:06 0.85
auchiedollie tracked neutrino 02:16 0.1
2 cmjhutton reference reference 02:19 0.99
3 Paul Gilbert reference reference 02:21 1.03
MassJam reference neutrino 02:23 0.26
4 mauefw tracked reference 02:25 0.95
5 Jason reference reference 02:38 0.84
Margaut tracked neutrino 02:39 0.01
6 verlaine reference reference 02:41 0.92
7 mistigris reference reference 02:42 1.06
8 hilarym reference reference 02:48 0.88
9 Magoo tracked reference 02:50 0.95
10 aphis99 reference reference 02:54 1.03
C M Gilles tracked neutrino 03:10 -0.03
michaelbell53 reference neutrino 03:14 0.39
11 SGHanson new_solver reference 03:18 0.64
12 Flimmy flammy reference reference 03:21 1.1
13 Ciolf new_solver reference 03:41 0.85
14 richard reference reference 03:41 0.77
MelindaE tracked neutrino 03:43 0.29
15 markdobell reference reference 03:44 0.93
16 Heyesey reference reference 03:47 0.98
17 Sheapey tracked reference 03:47 1.07
18 glheard reference reference 04:03 0.83
19 AlanS reference reference 04:03 0.63
20 Amoeba89 new_solver tracked 04:03 1.46
21 SimonAnthony tracked reference 04:06 1.1
22 Kinghedger reference reference 04:07 0.96
23 Topical Tim reference reference 04:13 1.19
24 MikeOsborne reference reference 04:17 1.15
25 Deane Short new_solver reference 04:17 1.17
26 Umpire reference tracked 04:20 1.19
27 lickert reference reference 04:24 1.02
28 Golvellius tracked reference 04:25 1.42
29 Morphosis new_solver reference 04:33 0.52
30 Roscoe reference reference 04:34 0.8
31 John Walsh tracked tracked 04:37 0.43
32 toots new_solver reference 04:38 0.7
33 jaha new_solver reference 04:38 1.46
34 chindit reference reference 04:39 0.79
drginacoco tracked neutrino 04:41 1.99
35 MK76 reference reference 04:43 1.04
36 philjordan1147 reference reference 04:44 0.89
37 Glencairn new_solver reference 04:46 0.88
38 cdb_100 new_solver reference 04:47 1.36
39 Bluejacket new_solver reference 04:47 1.04
chriswords tracked neutrino 04:48 0.21
40 lucyg43484 reference reference 04:48 1.13
41 alexh reference reference 04:50 0.74
42 Tom Stubbs reference reference 04:51 0.91
43 fshephe reference reference 04:52 0.67
44 tilbee reference reference 04:53 1.06
45 EricK new_solver reference 04:54 1.04
46 Jon Delfin tracked reference 04:55 0.8
47 Paul Bacon tracked tracked 04:55 0.23
48 Freemers tracked reference 04:56 0.93
49 scrabbler reference reference 04:57 0.93
50 LuckOfLucien new_solver reference 04:57 0.97
51 canismiser reference reference 04:57 1.3
52 andrewlake reference reference 04:57 1.11
53 LouWeed reference reference 04:59 1.08
54 McBeakLives new_solver reference 05:00 1.0
55 Liari reference reference 05:00 0.68
56 tiggis reference reference 05:00 0.87
57 JayEm new_solver reference 05:01 0.96
58 Honggui reference reference 05:02 1.21
59 footballblue reference reference 05:04 0.61
60 andy reference reference 05:05 0.95
61 March reference reference 05:06 0.95
62 d.middleton reference reference 05:06 1.22
moirconsult new_solver neutrino 05:09 -0.17
wwalker50 reference neutrino 05:09 0.16
63 Ed freshpot reference reference 05:11 1.19
64 denislaw reference tracked 05:12 0.41
65 neilr reference reference 05:12 0.63
66 Aybee new_solver reference 05:14 1.44
67 Aly Duncan reference reference 05:16 0.92
68 pitcaithlie reference reference 05:20 0.86
69 7dPenguin reference reference 05:22 1.1
70 ChuckB reference reference 05:22 0.71
71 DunPangolin reference reference 05:23 1.02
72 Tibthorpe reference reference 05:24 0.65
73 alisonm74 new_solver reference 05:24 0.48
74 Zander reference reference 05:25 1.0
75 Squallaby reference reference 05:26 1.25
76 cmcnsmith reference reference 05:28 0.48
77 Adelaider new_solver reference 05:30 1.01
78 AndyKnott321 new_solver reference 05:31 0.63
79 nina s reference reference 05:31 0.85
80 Crossiant reference reference 05:33 1.26
81 GeorgeTz reference reference 05:36 0.56
82 Riche reference reference 05:38 0.92
83 Finzi reference reference 05:38 0.6
84 Rinteff tracked reference 05:38 0.59
85 whichcraft new_solver reference 05:41 1.05
86 Paul Hammond reference reference 05:43 0.96
87 MrChumley reference reference 05:44 0.78
88 rrricharrrd new_solver reference 05:45 1.34
89 Penfold_61 reference reference 05:45 0.98
90 esmeralda reference reference 05:46 1.52
91 Encota new_solver reference 05:51 1.45
92 chriswestontour new_solver reference 05:54 0.63
93 KET reference reference 05:58 0.87
94 Vannyx new_solver reference 06:00 1.15
95 mw7000 reference reference 06:01 1.29
96 The Dabbler tracked reference 06:01 0.73
97 fishernick79 tracked reference 06:02 1.0
98 mcrossib1 tracked reference 06:02 1.36
99 Streaky Bacon new_solver reference 06:03 1.48
100 RobR tracked reference 06:04 1.02
101 Looch reference reference 06:04 1.03
102 Rabbitoh reference reference 06:05 1.28
Sreffej new_solver neutrino 06:07 -0.69
103 cath23 reference reference 06:09 1.59
104 chrismarch tracked reference 06:09 1.12
105 hopkinb reference reference 06:11 1.01
106 PGooden reference reference 06:15 1.17
107 KarenR new_solver reference 06:15 1.22
108 Rosron reference reference 06:15 0.91
109 Jeremy Weissmann reference reference 06:15 1.2
110 Mike C new_solver reference 06:15 0.95
111 andrewfeist96 new_solver reference 06:20 1.05
112 Gaius new_solver reference 06:21 1.64
113 SBQuick new_solver reference 06:21 1.34
114 plusjeremy new_solver reference 06:27 1.55
115 dr.shred new_solver reference 06:28 0.85
116 julian_w reference reference 06:29 1.15
117 Carol reference reference 06:31 1.13
118 PuzzleMaestro tracked tracked 06:31 2.21
119 Anomalospiza new_solver reference 06:32 1.9
120 Adrian Cobb new_solver reference 06:32 0.88
121 ramf new_solver reference 06:34 1.36
122 jimwetzler reference reference 06:35 0.77
123 tom.healey new_solver reference 06:35 0.99
124 hofzinser new_solver reference 06:36 0.64
125 Onelug new_solver reference 06:36 1.46
126 Dzhigit reference reference 06:39 1.13
127 Shabbo reference reference 06:39 1.35
128 wrgrs new_solver reference 06:42 0.83
129 Tudds reference reference 06:46 1.32
130 thewanderingeditor new_solver reference 06:46 1.24
131 paul.whitehouse69 reference reference 06:48 1.17
132 Kalakuta72 reference reference 06:49 1.25
133 Curarist tracked tracked 06:49 1.07
134 jon reference reference 06:51 1.28
135 GMcD reference reference 06:52 1.07
136 JoeyC tracked tracked 06:56 2.35
137 Michael Dove reference reference 06:56 1.48
138 mfg1971 tracked reference 06:58 1.33
139 hazyfantazee new_solver reference 06:59 1.02
140 ilan reference reference 06:59 0.9
141 Aloysius reference reference 07:03 1.42
142 endafk reference reference 07:06 1.14
143 Willie F new_solver reference 07:07 1.11
144 janesa new_solver reference 07:13 1.04
145 Manveru new_solver reference 07:14 1.04
146 uvofiz reference reference 07:14 0.93
147 robertL new_solver reference 07:15 1.04
148 Nangle reference reference 07:15 1.19
149 tds tracked reference 07:16 0.97
150 Kevin Gregg reference reference 07:18 0.66
151 adamhanley71 new_solver reference 07:19 0.77
152 CrystalPip tracked reference 07:19 1.1
153 Gussie reference reference 07:21 1.25
154 James P reference reference 07:22 1.39
155 Obrador new_solver reference 07:22 0.89
156 earlylight reference reference 07:23 1.3
157 robertbridge tracked reference 07:23 1.31
158 robinh reference reference 07:28 0.87
159 FraserH reference reference 07:29 1.1
160 Rembleforth new_solver reference 07:29 0.81
161 KenD51 reference reference 07:32 1.1
162 DianeRS reference reference 07:32 1.33
163 Jamie Fox new_solver reference 07:34 1.6
164 valerian1967 tracked reference 07:34 1.29
165 Desdeeloeste new_solver reference 07:37 0.9
166 Puzzleplease reference reference 07:38 0.84
167 jjspomeroy tracked reference 07:42 1.17
168 DamienKnapma new_solver reference 07:43 0.78
169 Nigel1953 new_solver tracked 07:46 2.26
170 Mike Harper reference reference 07:47 1.07
171 nigel reference reference 07:52 1.1
172 Aldus new_solver reference 07:52 0.92
173 banishspam new_solver tracked 07:52 0.25
174 docg tracked reference 07:53 0.5
175 SlumdogEngineer reference reference 07:54 1.98
176 1234 reference reference 07:54 0.73
177 wwicksteed tracked reference 07:55 0.77
178 Corymbia reference reference 07:57 0.95
179 ChrisBrea reference reference 07:58 1.21
180 edwards.robert1 tracked reference 08:00 0.75
181 martinede reference reference 08:00 0.6
182 Dvynys reference reference 08:01 1.33
183 TomHerbert reference reference 08:01 0.8
184 td349 new_solver reference 08:02 1.27
185 mjwiseman tracked reference 08:08 0.81
186 Claverton74 tracked reference 08:10 0.53
187 mjsaunders9 new_solver reference 08:11 0.61
188 plett11 reference reference 08:23 1.34
189 jaraab reference reference 08:29 0.85
190 Templar Redux reference reference 08:30 1.16
191 GMB tracked reference 08:31 0.96
192 John Arnold reference reference 08:33 0.9
193 smalley552 tracked reference 08:36 1.27
194 alastair52 reference reference 08:38 0.82
195 ulaca reference reference 08:38 1.4
196 Jamescheck new_solver reference 08:39 1.23
197 john.brassey tracked reference 08:39 1.2
198 steve.laverock new_solver reference 08:39 1.26
199 Sheen reference reference 08:40 1.29
puzzled1 tracked neutrino 08:40 1.0
200 vinyl12345 reference reference 08:45 1.3
201 Doyler tracked reference 08:45 1.72
202 Jeeves tracked reference 08:47 0.84
203 vefatica tracked tracked 08:48 0.39
204 JanieP new_solver reference 08:49 1.6
205 goblin reference reference 08:49 0.69
206 davidatcdm tracked reference 08:50 1.42
207 jemcd33 tracked reference 08:53 1.23
208 Calculator001 tracked reference 08:54 1.49
209 Cuppa378 tracked reference 08:54 1.03
210 Rosey6 new_solver reference 08:54 0.55
211 johndun reference reference 08:57 1.04
212 Zabadak3 tracked reference 08:57 0.89
213 mattindoha reference reference 08:57 0.99
214 MichelinPoitiers new_solver reference 09:00 1.18
215 alex.scordellis tracked reference 09:00 1.36
216 cerds tracked reference 09:01 1.68
217 m5harp reference reference 09:03 1.02
218 ratterz reference reference 09:04 1.31
219 kath tracked reference 09:04 1.16
220 OldSolver tracked reference 09:09 1.36
221 hemantyd new_solver reference 09:09 1.18
222 nigelmzzz tracked reference 09:11 0.92
223 timbo reference reference 09:13 1.02
224 dec tracked reference 09:13 0.91
225 crucihacker new_solver reference 09:13 1.09
226 luxtonj61 reference reference 09:14 0.91
227 Manuel1 tracked reference 09:15 1.04
228 Mkgnao tracked reference 09:18 1.15
229 ezoredfox tracked reference 09:21 1.67
230 gsriordan52 reference reference 09:22 0.87
231 garsoli new_solver reference 09:27 1.49
232 crosswordian reference reference 09:27 0.94
233 Eider new_solver reference 09:28 0.48
234 Maitresse new_solver reference 09:32 1.44
235 Dr_Bob tracked reference 09:32 1.22
236 Edprof reference reference 09:32 1.11
237 Peloton new_solver reference 09:33 1.26
238 barracuda reference reference 09:36 1.03
239 annbrew reference reference 09:37 0.73
240 RPY tracked reference 09:37 1.33
241 raincloud reference reference 09:40 1.57
242 lemmings new_solver reference 09:41 1.31
243 Deezzaa reference reference 09:43 1.15
244 f4rch new_solver reference 09:43 1.53
245 dedly new_solver reference 09:44 0.84
246 JeffHobbs tracked reference 09:46 1.42
247 mamster new_solver reference 09:46 1.83
248 hookyt tracked reference 09:47 1.54
249 Word Psmith new_solver reference 09:56 0.93
250 mich_punk new_solver reference 09:58 0.97
251 Mike Mansbridge reference reference 10:00 1.48
252 Cryptique tracked reference 10:02 1.07
253 CoxBurglar tracked reference 10:02 1.17
254 Poff new_solver reference 10:04 1.16
255 ofarrell new_solver reference 10:07 1.1
256 Coffell new_solver reference 10:10 1.15
257 FelicityTT tracked reference 10:14 1.26
258 piltdown man new_solver reference 10:14 1.17
259 Troothful tracked reference 10:20 1.5
260 Seagulls58 new_solver reference 10:23 1.89
261 kate new_solver tracked 10:23 3.21
262 richardCV22 new_solver reference 10:25 0.85
263 flashman tracked blog_solver 10:31 1.22
264 annikins new_solver reference 10:35 1.32
265 Married Admirer new_solver reference 10:37 1.69
266 Alias Noble new_solver reference 10:38 1.74
267 Solfynn new_solver reference 10:46 0.66
268 alexngbr tracked reference 10:51 1.26
269 Laputan tracked reference 10:52 1.51
270 The Mighty Salmon new_solver reference 10:52 1.38
271 Birdingbob tracked reference 10:55 1.22
272 Nuck_the_king tracked reference 11:01 1.02
273 johnwynnewilliams new_solver reference 11:03 1.13
274 starstruck new_solver reference 11:08 1.19
SMSEsq new_solver neutrino 11:14 0.13
275 iholloway tracked reference 11:15 1.44
276 intentional rounding new_solver reference 11:19 1.32
277 Pendrov tracked reference 11:21 1.45
278 TonyN6 reference reference 11:23 1.02
279 SlowSteady tracked reference 11:23 0.77
280 paul.verney new_solver reference 11:24 0.74
281 symbenall2 new_solver reference 11:25 1.16
282 russellcannon new_solver reference 11:28 1.53
283 Corbo new_solver reference 11:33 0.86
284 phatman new_solver reference 11:39 1.33
285 simjt tracked reference 11:39 1.02
286 rlowin2 new_solver reference 11:41 0.73
287 horners1974 new_solver reference 11:48 1.62
288 Dr. Memory tracked tracked 11:49 0.24
289 Captain Burnaby new_solver reference 11:50 1.53
290 maggiema new_solver reference 11:51 1.26
291 Pauline Minter tracked reference 11:52 0.76
292 maisiemae reference reference 11:55 2.0
293 BertieVII tracked reference 11:59 1.04
294 E Bradford tracked reference 12:01 1.27
295 youngbaz new_solver reference 12:06 1.1
296 WordPlodder tracked reference 12:12 1.16
297 banni-wae new_solver reference 12:12 0.96
298 Richard the First new_solver reference 12:20 1.05
299 Struwa tracked reference 12:20 0.53
300 alistair.boere new_solver reference 12:28 1.05
301 Adele Bright new_solver tracked 12:35 2.7
302 The Real Steve Snackman new_solver reference 12:36 1.12
303 jackk.larg tracked reference 12:44 1.37
304 suethepotterer tracked reference 12:46 0.76
305 MartianAlien new_solver tracked 12:47 0.28
306 Monkos tracked tracked 12:51 2.34
307 Sonofjim tracked reference 12:55 1.15
308 chabuduo tracked reference 13:01 1.53
309 martinr486 new_solver reference 13:03 0.88
310 kapietro tracked reference 13:07 0.83
311 hectorslave new_solver reference 13:08 0.86
312 tyrotim new_solver reference 13:12 1.36
313 ifincham2 tracked reference 13:14 0.77
314 nick.wilson new_solver reference 13:29 0.62
315 Hugster new_solver tracked 13:39 2.02
316 Rammy Trainor new_solver reference 13:50 1.23
317 trish_tang new_solver reference 13:57 1.22
RaghuS new_solver neutrino 13:59 0.24
318 Doofenschmirtz tracked blog_solver 14:05 1.33
319 domski new_solver reference 14:16 1.97
320 jarenstein new_solver tracked 14:19 3.54
321 Mendes tracked reference 14:23 1.31
322 mpbthorpe new_solver reference 14:23 1.48
323 MichaelE tracked reference 14:27 1.56
324 Charpentier new_solver reference 14:41 0.51
325 Merlin new_solver blog_solver 14:53 1.06
14 Across new_solver neutrino 14:58 0.19
326 dan_tman new_solver reference 15:05 1.27
327 JanetP new_solver reference 15:07 1.78
328 Steve Wood new_solver reference 15:10 1.09
329 Muckypuppy new_solver reference 15:15 1.46
clivejharlow new_solver neutrino 15:25 0.2
330 Mozbo new_solver reference 15:27 1.33
331 Chrisa9 new_solver tracked 15:30 3.64
332 Guy Hatton new_solver reference 15:31 1.25
333 Xebeq tracked reference 15:31 1.1
334 Mark from Ipswich new_solver reference 15:46 1.26
335 kfb20 tracked reference 16:01 1.47
336 Holly O new_solver reference 16:02 1.26
337 K_estrel new_solver reference 16:21 1.44
338 Jax74 new_solver reference 16:26 0.58
339 robert.buchele new_solver tracked 16:28 2.56
340 thechan new_solver reference 16:29 0.6
341 david.14587 new_solver reference 16:34 1.47
342 RPE10538 tracked reference 16:44 1.38
343 pfalloon tracked tracked 16:52 2.13
344 Narayanan new_solver tracked 17:00 0.42
Cathyhuns new_solver neutrino 17:06 0.3
345 hcmsm new_solver tracked 17:13 2.11
346 140 Mandak 262 Jamuna new_solver reference 17:14 0.97
347 danielbluebisson new_solver reference 17:49 1.75
348 tomtom2 new_solver reference 17:54 1.27
349 Boostage new_solver reference 18:20 0.63
350 james new_solver reference 18:31 1.53
351 keithandginnybirrell new_solver reference 18:34 1.42
352 winelover new_solver reference 19:43 1.18
353 TonyK new_solver reference 19:48 0.89
354 anderson1965 new_solver reference 19:54 1.79
355 ian.shepherd new_solver reference 20:08 0.62
356 Jack-in-the-box new_solver reference 20:16 0.82
357 ttto new_solver reference 20:29 1.16
358 Hazelnut new_solver reference 21:14 0.46
359 RK123 new_solver reference 21:21 1.5
360 david new_solver reference 21:22 0.79
361 maryht new_solver reference 21:28 0.64
362 daverob new_solver reference 21:36 1.27
363 Jean in Oxford new_solver reference 21:39 1.2
Yiggsy new_solver neutrino 21:50 0.18
364 bangsar new_solver reference 22:03 1.54
365 Jilks new_solver reference 22:20 0.55
366 Dofray reference reference 22:24 1.2
367 philby new_solver reference 22:28 1.27
368 dominic.c-b new_solver reference 22:36 1.05
369 judi new_solver tracked 22:37 2.36
370 NAJM new_solver reference 22:46 0.79
371 SilleG new_solver tracked 23:01 2.13
372 Pontypandy new_solver reference 23:27 1.86
373 Askani new_solver reference 23:27 0.87
374 WayneO new_solver reference 23:47 1.22
375 Tired_commuter new_solver reference 23:52 1.3
376 Damien Grover new_solver tracked 24:23 2.25
377 pamelalewis51 new_solver reference 24:33 0.63
378 Pompeydave tracked reference 24:47 0.51
379 mozbadel new_solver reference 25:43 0.67
380 MrMonro new_solver reference 25:44 0.83
381 paulmcl tracked tracked 26:35 0.96
382 jlloyd4424 new_solver reference 26:43 1.29
383 Flora Garden new_solver reference 26:45 1.19
384 shankar new_solver reference 27:07 0.95
385 Aresbiscuits new_solver tracked 28:20 2.18
386 Sotogrande1 new_solver reference 28:25 1.5
387 deebeeem new_solver reference 28:45 1.11
388 Edmonton Euler new_solver reference 29:35 0.95
389 DrAnatomist new_solver reference 31:03 0.65
dave new_solver neutrino 32:20 -0.04
390 IanV new_solver reference 32:42 0.75
prognosticat new_solver neutrino 37:05 0.14
391 revolting tonic new_solver tracked 39:10 0.39
392 Jay_W new_solver reference 40:14 1.09
393 kevinlimanta new_solver reference 40:40 0.94
394 Jikolp new_solver reference 42:09 0.86
395 brett.anthony new_solver reference 42:31 0.85
396 lilias.allan new_solver tracked 46:28 1.19
397 mcfarl new_solver tracked 46:36 1.04
398 stephenpmars new_solver tracked 47:04 1.79
399 crossworder new_solver tracked 51:32 1.39